Nude Protest, Taiwan Style
Taiwan had another of its nude protests today. Unfortunately, unless you live in Taiwan, you're highly unlikely to ever hear of it, let alone see it. Yes, Taiwan's TV stations and evening newspaper had short reports and limited footage about the action, but it hardly shook up the island.
As on previous occasions, this nude protest was staged by a professor and his students with environmental pollution as the target. But otherwise, the protest was hardly a major happening.
First, it was staged in Taihsi, a town most Taiwanese have never been to, in Yunlin County, in the south of the country, far away from the national capital and media center, Taipei. Most local media, and certainly the international media, will not send a news team down there unless there's a major accident or natural disaster.
Second, the footage seemed to reveal there were five participants in the protest. Yes, you read that, five people went naked against pollution.
Third, the five men - no women - spend some time in the water, with the water up to their waist, holding up placards saying that pollution would turn Taihsi into another New Orleans. Necessary hyperbole to get media attention? Hardly, almost a laughable comparison.
This nude protest is not going to achieve anything more than previous protests have. People will read about it in the paper, shake their head, and continue their daily lives.
If a nude protest is going to make any impact, it will have to be larger, more concentrated, and at the right place.
You'll need not five, not a dozen, but dozens, preferably over a hundred people in various stages of undress, and yes, women as well as men. All the protesters will have to stand together, to create an event of Spencer Tunick scale - you know, the American photographer who has crowds of people pose nude in the streets of a world city - and more important, you will have the protesters gather at a central location where media coverage is certain.
And in Taiwan, I know only two places that would be perfect for such a protest: the Chiang Kai-shek Memorial Hall, with its huge plaza familiar with tourists as well as regular protesters, and Ketagalan Boulevard, the wide avenue in front of the Presidential Office Building, the scene of many protests in 2004.
But in the end, my personal opinion is that nudity is not really a protest weapon. It will shock some people and bring attention to the cause, or rather the protesters, but nudity should not shock. Nudity is human, and I'd much rather relax nude on a beach, sunbathe on my terrace, and do sports in the nude, rather than be walking around in the middle of a hot city.
As on previous occasions, this nude protest was staged by a professor and his students with environmental pollution as the target. But otherwise, the protest was hardly a major happening.
First, it was staged in Taihsi, a town most Taiwanese have never been to, in Yunlin County, in the south of the country, far away from the national capital and media center, Taipei. Most local media, and certainly the international media, will not send a news team down there unless there's a major accident or natural disaster.
Second, the footage seemed to reveal there were five participants in the protest. Yes, you read that, five people went naked against pollution.
Third, the five men - no women - spend some time in the water, with the water up to their waist, holding up placards saying that pollution would turn Taihsi into another New Orleans. Necessary hyperbole to get media attention? Hardly, almost a laughable comparison.
This nude protest is not going to achieve anything more than previous protests have. People will read about it in the paper, shake their head, and continue their daily lives.
If a nude protest is going to make any impact, it will have to be larger, more concentrated, and at the right place.
You'll need not five, not a dozen, but dozens, preferably over a hundred people in various stages of undress, and yes, women as well as men. All the protesters will have to stand together, to create an event of Spencer Tunick scale - you know, the American photographer who has crowds of people pose nude in the streets of a world city - and more important, you will have the protesters gather at a central location where media coverage is certain.
And in Taiwan, I know only two places that would be perfect for such a protest: the Chiang Kai-shek Memorial Hall, with its huge plaza familiar with tourists as well as regular protesters, and Ketagalan Boulevard, the wide avenue in front of the Presidential Office Building, the scene of many protests in 2004.
But in the end, my personal opinion is that nudity is not really a protest weapon. It will shock some people and bring attention to the cause, or rather the protesters, but nudity should not shock. Nudity is human, and I'd much rather relax nude on a beach, sunbathe on my terrace, and do sports in the nude, rather than be walking around in the middle of a hot city.